ON THIS DAY IN… 1980: PAUL SIMON – ONE TRICK PONY

12 August 2026 John Bensalhia

A One Trick Pony blogger writes about a One Trick Pony album…

Late In The Evening
Nearly five years had passed by 1980 without a new Paul Simon studio album.

The last anyone had heard of him was the compilation, Greatest Hits Etc in 1977, which had featured two new tracks, Slip Slidin’ Away and Stranded In A Limousine. However, by the late Summer of 1980, a new project had been announced – a movie and accompanying soundtrack album of the same name.

One Trick Pony isn’t admittedly the first Paul Simon album that pops up in discussion, but it’s streets ahead of his previous studio offering, the maudlin ennui of Still Crazy After All These Years. Late In The Evening boasts more energy than the whole of that album put together, a rhythmic blaster that in hindsight sounds like the older brother of You Can Call Me Al. It has the same kind of beat to it, a percussion and brass-heavy foot-tapper that swiftly lodges inside the brain. Even Simon’s vocals sound revitalised and full of vim after a lengthy break, as he recalls his early memories growing up.

Taken as the teaser single for the album, Late In The Evening did have mixed chart fortunes. While it proved popular on Simon’s home turf (Number Six on the Hot 100), as well as in Israel, Zimbabwe and the Netherlands (all Top 10), it sadly stalled in the UK at Number 58. It’s a curious oversight from the UK record buying public that makes this track less well known than it should be.

That’s Why God Made The Movies
I’ll confess that I hadn’t seen the accompanying movie until yesterday in preparation for this latest bit of written nonsense. It’s a curiously downbeat affair, a tale of a failing rock star called Jonah Levin (played by Simon). The world seems to revel in kicking Jonah in the teeth. Not only are his aspirations of being a huge megastar on the skids, his marriage to Marion is crumbling more than an over-cooked biscuit. If you’re seeking a feelgood 90 minutes of escapism, this may not be the movie for you.

In its own quiet way though, the movie is worth a look. An interesting character-based drama, at least you can come away from it thinking that your life isn’t as relentlessly miserable as Jonah, as Simon’s hangdog expression gets more and more crumpled by the time the credits roll.

The only question I do have is over some of the musical choices for certain scenes. Take the bit in which he hangs out with his young son Matty. The music playing in the background is the chilled-out ponder, That’s Why God Made The Movies. Despite its laidback shuffle, the lyrics make for grim reading, all about a mother who died at childbirth, with the young son wondering why and what’s to become of him. I suppose at a pinch, that feeling of abandonment could extend to Matty, as he wonders why his dad has favoured a flailing and failing rock career over a happy family life.

One Trick Pony
If you ever wondered about celebrated writer Douglas Adams’ writing habits, then wonder no more.

For the man himself would create his works of fiction by two-touch typing along to his favourite records, one of which was Paul Simon’s One Trick Pony. I can heartily recommend this method, as the title track has a great, funky beat to two-touch type along to. And if you’re especially retro, try typing along on an old typewriter. Every time the bass does that funny chord whizz every five or so seconds, you can do the same by whizzing the middle typewriter bar back to the start.

Another highlight of the album, this was recorded live at Cleveland’s Agora Theatre and Ballroom in September 1979. I suppose the lyrics sum up Jonah’s plight quite well. While he may be seen by some as a One Trick Pony, what he does, he does well. “He makes it look so easy, it looks so clean, he moves like God’s immaculate machine.” Some may even speculate that it’s about the critics’ opinions of Simon himself over the years. But this particular critic thinks that Simon was far far more talented than that, and this track is a good example of his superlative songwriting skills and playing.

How The Heart Approaches What It Yearns
No matter how much he plays on the road and how often he makes whoopee with random club waitresses, Jonah’s heart still belongs with his wife, Marion. This track pops up twice in the movie – firstly, when Jonah calls Marion from his hotel room, and later, when he goes to visit Marion post-divorce and ends up sleeping with her again!

A fragile ballad, sung with sensitivity by Simon – who also does fine work with that nylon string guitar solo. And all this in a movie that features cameos from the likes of Lou Reed, The B-52s and Mr Burns himself, Harry Shearer!

Oh, Marion
Looking at the accompanying movie, I quickly realised that Oh, Marion is its centrepiece. The words sums up Jonah’s problem – best witnessed in “The boy’s got brains, he just refuses to use ’em and that’s all.” So dedicated to his ambition, Jonah’s switched off his brain cells and forgotten what really matters in the process – a loving wife and a family life. The lyrics in the chorus are as sharp as a tack, too: “The only time that love is an easy game is when two other people are playing it.”

This is one of Simon’s most underrated efforts. The lyrics are slyly clever, and they’re married to an unusual mid-tempo shuffle that delights with its oddball chord arrangement, almost making off for a different melody when it comes to the chorus.

Ace In The Hole
The other track recorded live the previous year at the Agora, this is a lengthy jazz-funk workout, nearly reaching six minutes (by far, the longest on the album). It’s a duet with pianist Richard Tee, whose soulful growl makes for an effective contrast with Simon’s own vocals.

This is a fine showcase for Simon’s accompanying band on this project – all of whom appear in the movie. Steve Gadd thumps the skins with strength and pinpoint precision. Tony Levin’s bass guitar work is fluid and also unusual, conjuring up a whole bag of tricks to sterling effect. Meanwhile, Tee’s Fender Rhodes electric piano sums up all of those classic late ’70s soul tracks – such an evocative sound. All of these combined talents work their hardest to create something special.

Nobody
If One Trick Pony can occasionally become a bit mopey on tracks like this, at least it strikes a better balance than Still Crazy, which pulled the long face for practically all of its album length (off the top of my head, the only time it cheers up is on 50 Ways To Leave Your Lover and Gone At Last, and even then the latter example isn’t much cop, anyway).

But then in the context of the movie, you’re not exactly going to expect a disco party for the scene in which Jonah is prepared to split from Marion. “Nobody but you,” moans Simon in sorrow, against a wall of sound backdrop of his own multi-dubbed aaahs. Well-played and well-arranged, but downcast.

Jonah
Jonah’s theme song is also quite sad – the electric piano solo fade out is especially maudlin. I suppose it’s quite apt that it’s played near the end of the movie when Simon’s character takes the master tape of his album, puts it in a guitar case, walks to a nearby street, takes the tape out, and then destroys it. A bleak end to a bleak movie.

Lyrically, Simon compares Jonah the movie character with the fictional Jonah who was swallowed by a whale. “I know Jonah, he was swallowed by a song,” reflects Simon, who ponders on the fate of a man totally consumed by the music business. So committed to realising his dream, Jonah didn’t for one minute think that he’d be completely chewed up by the industry and then spat out.

God Bless The Absentee
Some nice string work on this from Dave Grusin, as Simon attempts to justify Jonah’s decisions. At one point, he compares Jonah with a surgeon, claiming that music is his knife. “It cuts away my sorrow and purifies my life.”

Do we walk away feeling sorry for Jonah? He’s a complex character for sure, selfish and single-minded on the one hand, but then, we do see those flashes of vulnerability in the movie, such as when he breaks down in tears in front of Marion. That final scene suggests that maybe he’s looking to put down his surgeon’s knife for good. Perhaps the absentee’s coming home.

Long Long Day
This makes for a far more satisfactory album closer than the wretched Silent Eyes (for me, it’s the nadir of Simon’s otherwise impressive career) did on Still Crazy After All These Years. A lilting ballad with a bit of vocal help again from Patti Austin, who I talked about a couple of blogs ago on Jacko’s Off The Wall. Believe me, reader, this isn’t deliberate – it’s just one of those funny coincidences that these musicians get talked about at least twice.

One Trick Pony made a steady gallop around the global charts. Sweden, Norway, Holland and New Zealand awarded it Top 10 chart placings, but in America, it whinnied at Number 12 (and only Number 17 in the UK charts). Not a flop by any means, but compared to earlier releases, it didn’t quite hit the spot as well as it could have done.

Possibly, the fact that it was a soundtrack might have put some off. The movie didn’t hit the heights of say, Grease or Saturday Night Fever, instead remaining an interesting cult curiosity. I guess that status extends to the album’s standing. It’s never mentioned in the same ballpark as say, Graceland, Rhymin’ Simon – or even Still Crazy, which if not to my taste, did do very well chart-wise. But for those checking out Paul Simon’s extensive back catalogue of work, and coming to this album for the first time, I think they may be pleasantly surprised…

(Cover design credited to Lubalin, Peckolick Associates, photography credited to Louis Goldman)

If you liked this article, you might like some of my other books which are available to buy at Amazon:

Amazon.co.uk: JOHN BENSALHIA: books, biography, latest update

GET IN TOUCH